July 2015 WordPress News – This Month in WordPress w/ CodeinWP (#wpdrama Edition)

July was a hot month.

And I’m not talking about the temperature our side of the globe.

It’s the WordPress community that’s been on fire for weeks in a row, as Matt Mullenweg and Chris Pearson had a “small” conflict that turned into a very controversial and popular topic among the WordPress people.

It’s even got its own hashtag – #wpdrama.

And we’ve been paying attention just like the rest of the community. So:

What you’re reading here is a special edition of our series – This Month in WordPress w/ CodeinWP – the monthly roundup of news related to WordPress. This month, we’re making the report 100% #wpdrama exclusive.

 See the most important articles, comments, and tweets that tell the story of this year’s Mullenweg vs. Pearson battle. 

The news that started the fire

Chris Pearson Loses Cybersquatting Case Against Automattic

Automattic wins the fight over the Thesis.com domain, which started in late 2014, and has turned into a process somewhat like the Cold War. Summing up:

  • In late 2014, Chris Pearson wanted (or rather, was considering) to buy the domain name from a third-party, but Automattic made the final step and snatched it for $100k.
  • Pearson didn’t accept losing the domain and right after the incident asked for a case review to transfer the domain from Automattic to himself.
  • Last month, a three-member panel was appointed to review the case and declared that Pearson had no sufficient submissions and also couldn’t prove that Automattic used the domain name in bad faith.
wptavern
And this is how #wpdrama begins. On June 16th 2015, Automattic advanced a petition with the United States Patent and Trademark Office to cancel the trademarks owned by Pearson: DIYTHEMES, THESIS THEME, and THESIS.

Things gained weight quickly, didn’t they?


Pearson tells his side of the story

The Truth About Thesis.com

The way things were unfolding compelled Chris Pearson to write a rather long post on his blog, where he discussed the entire story, along with some aspects of it that were not common knowledge up to that point.

In the post, Pearson talks about his motives and his reasoning behind the decisions he’s made along Thesis’ lifespan.

He also tells the story of releasing Thesis for a fee, and as a result seeing Mullenweg disagreeing and pointing out that big portions of Pearson’s work hold code copied from WordPress, which therefore makes the whole project GPL by definition (as it derives from WordPress).

pearsonified
Pearson also discusses the story of the Thesis.com domain’s acquisition in great detail and how it all played out on a timeline (who did what and when).

Mullenweg didn’t miss the opportunity to reply to Pearson’s article, and a long and fierce debate started.

Some of Mullenweg’s interesting comment responses:

matt domain reply matt gpl
matt reply domain matt gpl 2

Outside perspectives

  • Thesis, Automattic, and WordPress
    Brian Krogsgard of PostStatus published a really in-depth take on the whole dispute, starting from the very beginning, right up to the situation we have today. Certainly worth a read if you have some free time (10,000 words).
  • Why All The #wpdrama ??
    Josh Pollock of JoshPress.net presented an interesting take on the drama. Focusing more on the things that remain in the background and the realities of doing business on the web and in the WordPress space.
  • My strategy for navigating the WordPress world
    Another interesting take on the whole matter, this time coming from Chris Lema. No direct #wpdrama commentary here, though. Instead, Lema focuses on the art of being part of the WordPress community, navigating the WordPress world and how to spend our time more productively.


Twitter turned into a battlefield

Tons of comments and conversations sprouted from this controversy (it’s actually where the hashtag #wpdrama was born):



The early beginnings of the rivalry

interview
Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis, A Leading WordPress Theme? – with Chris Pearson and Matt Mullenweg

Matt Mullenweg and Chris Pearson first clashed directly back in 2010 as part of an interview conducted by Andrew Warner of Mixergy.

TL;DR: Mullenweg points out that what Pearson is doing violates the license and is disrespectful to thousands of people who built WordPress, while Pearson insists Thesis theme is his personal protected work and he doesn’t want to cede this right by going GPL.

Watch this interview if you’re into thrilling discussions and have some popcorn ready.

And how was your #wpdrama experience?

Say hi on

Adelina Tuca

Writer and WordPress blogger at ThemeIsle, CodeinWP, and Revive Social. When I'm not creating content, I'm either hiking, attending a metal concert, reading a book, or watching tennis.
Say hi on
  • OMG, this is so awesome! Didn’t know about it. Thanks for sharing! :)) So great!